Author Topic: Post random stuff here  (Read 598156 times)

0 Members and 7 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline EnzoMortelli

Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1905 on: September 30, 2015, 10:53:20 AM »
GTA 5 Online needs some of the LW admen....  :'(

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMUB1pSWq80
I expected GTA Online hacks and not your votekick butthurt, i am disappoint :(

Hackers are not a big deal in GTA Online, as they are being sorted out into the cheater poll rather quickly and on a big scale.

Abusers are the real issue, as they keep doing their shit forever, as long as the automated anti-cheat / griefing system doesn't detect what they are doing. And that's the case with the kick feature.
Well the pro and con arguments on vote-kick systems are sufficiently acquainted. If you're playing a game where the playerbase has the opportunity to kick you out of game sessions for no specific reason you should be prepared to be subject to this system if you even provide a comprehensible reason no matter if the kick is justified in light of abstract rules or conventions the game or it's written rules do not enforce.
Re-reading the Wiki entries and reddit's etiquette for GTA Online, there is nothing that forbids voting annoying people out of jobs, and the enemy team was obviously annoyed by you for killing them fast. In fact going by these you've been a bad sport for being voted out of the match. Your frustration is comprehensible, but the behaviour you have witnessed is encouraged by the game.
The way i see it, you have three options:
  • Deal with it,
  • find another game that suits your expectations better or
  • keep playing it and keep shitposting in the forums of your old game how frustrating your new game is


Offline BikeDriver

  • Fisher
  • ******
  • Posts: 1765
  • I can do anything
    • Awards
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1906 on: September 30, 2015, 12:45:53 PM »
Well the pro and con arguments on vote-kick systems are sufficiently acquainted. If you're playing a game where the playerbase has the opportunity to kick you out of game sessions for no specific reason you should be prepared to be subject to this system if you even provide a comprehensible reason no matter if the kick is justified in light of abstract rules or conventions the game or it's written rules do not enforce.
Re-reading the Wiki entries and reddit's etiquette for GTA Online, there is nothing that forbids voting annoying people out of jobs, and the enemy team was obviously annoyed by you for killing them fast. In fact going by these you've been a bad sport for being voted out of the match. Your frustration is comprehensible, but the behaviour you have witnessed is encouraged by the game.
The way i see it, you have three options:
  • Deal with it,
  • find another game that suits your expectations better or
  • keep playing it and keep shitposting in the forums of your old game how frustrating your new game is
Meh... enzo why are you shit-talking me like that? Get that sand out of your vagina dude.

First off, I have not posted this video here because I was frustrated. I created this video mainly to get a discussion started on the GTA Online forums regarding this abuse and as I thought that some people here would find it interesting aswell, I have posted it here too. It shows nicely how the GTA Online Multiplayer in general and the anti-cheat system differs from LW/SA:MP. Seeing your reaction shows me that you indeed are interested.

However... now regarding your defence of the abusers (which is completely out of sense, considering you being a role-model for fairplay, thus leading to my first question of this post):
You are putting it as if I was the one to ruin the match. But the matchmaking is done by the game engine. I don't join "noob games" and bash noobs. I only have 1 account (legit level 235). The score was 3-3, so it's not as if I had an easy job. The score would have been 4-0 for the enemy if it wasn't for me. So the teams were somewhat balanced because of me. Not to mention that we were about 40 minutes into the job until they decided to kick me. Plus they had the chance to kick me before the job started (in the lobby). There they saw my level (not that my level was higher than theirs, lol).

You don't see it as a problem that you can kick an enemy out of a competitive job just because he is winning? That's ridiculous. And no matter how much you dislike me, arguing that this feature was intended to be used in that way is completely unreasonable.
« Last Edit: September 30, 2015, 01:21:30 PM by BikeDriver »
BikeDriv:))))

Haha blwelrwelrt, I registered here earlier :P

Offline bleeeh

  • Tiny Fish
  • *
  • Posts: 30
    • Awards
  • SA-MP: [r]V.
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1907 on: September 30, 2015, 02:10:17 PM »

Offline BikeDriver

  • Fisher
  • ******
  • Posts: 1765
  • I can do anything
    • Awards
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1908 on: September 30, 2015, 06:16:47 PM »
Here, this might actually help you out: http://www.pickthebrain.com/blog/improve-reading-comprehension/

You have waited for this moment, have you not? ;D

I am not failing to comprehend, I am reading between the lines. That's way more efficient and get's the "discussion" going 2000% faster.
BikeDriv:))))

Haha blwelrwelrt, I registered here earlier :P

Offline EnzoMortelli

Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1909 on: October 01, 2015, 09:54:30 AM »
[...]

Meh... enzo why are you shit-talking me like that? Get that sand out of your vagina dude.

First off, I have not posted this video here because I was frustrated. I created this video mainly to get a discussion started on the GTA Online forums regarding this abuse and as I thought that some people here would find it interesting aswell, I have posted it here too. It shows nicely how the GTA Online Multiplayer in general and the anti-cheat system differs from LW/SA:MP. Seeing your reaction shows me that you indeed are interested.

However... now regarding your defence of the abusers (which is completely out of sense, considering you being a role-model for fairplay, thus leading to my first question of this post):
You are putting it as if I was the one to ruin the match. But the matchmaking is done by the game engine. I don't join "noob games" and bash noobs. I only have 1 account (legit level 235). The score was 3-3, so it's not as if I had an easy job. The score would have been 4-0 for the enemy if it wasn't for me. So the teams were somewhat balanced because of me. Not to mention that we were about 40 minutes into the job until they decided to kick me. Plus they had the chance to kick me before the job started (in the lobby). There they saw my level (not that my level was higher than theirs, lol).

You don't see it as a problem that you can kick an enemy out of a competitive job just because he is winning? That's ridiculous. And no matter how much you dislike me, arguing that this feature was intended to be used in that way is completely unreasonable.
No, read again.
I don't allege that Rockstar implemented votekick in the intention of having the players kick their enemies when they are winning. Maybe i was a bit quick to presume the scope of consequences of implementing a votekick system, so i might explain further in more detail.

Votekick Systems
A votekick system is a system that allows all players of a match or a team equally to cast a vote against another player to remove said player from the current game session. If a sufficient ammount of people, usually playerpool size - x where x is in range of 1 to playerpoolsize/2+1, voted yes to get a player kicked said player will be removed based on the community decision. Votekick systems are mainly put in place to act as administrative measures that do not require a live administrator to be executed, thus reducing administrative effort.
Discussion:
+:
  • Instant handling of cheaters and rulebreakers through the community base without waiting time for an administrator.
  • Democratic structure ensures a fair based decision in theory.
  • As being limited to a kick the measures are not permanent thus the ammount of power in community does not imply further consequences.
-:
  • Specifying a reason for the kick is not necessary neither applicable, thus a reason is not necessary.
  • Following from the above point, the votekick system is not limited to reasonable or official offences but to any common reasoning or none at all.
  • The playerbase is not ensured to base their decisions on the necessary level of experience or even on a collaborative reason.


So to re-elaborate my previous post's paragraph:
If you play a game that implements a kind of administrative system you should be aware of how it works and what it's consequences are, because if you are playing the game you have agreed to be held subject to the administrative measures applicable in that game no matter if you have informed yourself or not. This is exactly the same at LWs. Only that the administrative power on LWs does not lie in the playerbase's hands (thank god) but in the responsibility of experienced administrators.

If you hold me up as a role-model of fairplay you did never understand my intentions from the beginning, because i am not. I'll explain this too just in case.
The ammount of fairplay in a game decides by the implementation design in the last release candidate version. (in theory, ofc inapplicable to early-access, beta-tests, DLCs, hotpatches, etc..) The implementation design is something the administrator has had no influence on. An administrator bases their decisions not on their or common understanding of fairness, but on a set of rules that are valid for the game they are administering. That the rules of LWs are so spot-on to the game balance that you have the feeling that administration's decisions are exceptionally fair is pure coincidence.
And to answer another thing you mentioned, from administrative viewpoint on Rockstar's side you were indeed the one ruining the round otherwise the community would not have voted you out, that is how a votekick system works and these are the consequences. And i can only repeat myself that i can unreservedly understand your problem with how this works, but if you await that i agree that it would be ridiculous, unreasonable or unjustified then i have to decline, because in the context of GTA Online it is not.
I understand that you tried to exert a comparisson of how unfair GTA:O's administration is compared to LW's administrative standards, but really there is no base to compare both because the GTA:O's administration works differently and does not follow our conventions thus applying LWs viewpoint to it simply does not suffice to draw a comparison.

tl;dr i am missing detailed examination of the matter in your posts. (Like i ever did not -_-)

Offline BikeDriver

  • Fisher
  • ******
  • Posts: 1765
  • I can do anything
    • Awards
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1910 on: October 01, 2015, 01:39:34 PM »
Chill, enzo retard stone frend,
Not going to shred your entire post apart, overall it makes sense, I admit.

But there is one major flaw, which is something you can't know if you never saw the GTA Online Session Kick in action:

  • Democratic structure ensures a fair based decision in theory.
It is not a fair based, democratic decision or structure, not even in theory, but as I said you couldn't know that. The problem is that nobody has the option to vote "No, don't kick him". You can either vote "Yes, kick him", or do nothing. As long as there are a few idiots in the job who team up, they can get somebody kicked.

But the main problem is, that the player amount needed to get somebody kicked is not related to the amount of players in the job. Even in a 30 player job, if 4 people vote for the same person within a  certain time-span, he is gone. Even if the other 25 players don't agree, they have no option to vote "no". It becomes funny when there is a 3 player job and two players want to get the third kicked. They simply can't.

And again: I wasn't the one to ruin the match. The people who voted for me to get kicked are the ones who ruined the match, as they broke the balance, which was perfect until they screwed around.
« Last Edit: October 01, 2015, 01:48:13 PM by BikeDriver »
BikeDriv:))))

Haha blwelrwelrt, I registered here earlier :P

Offline bleeeh

  • Tiny Fish
  • *
  • Posts: 30
    • Awards
  • SA-MP: [r]V.
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1911 on: October 01, 2015, 01:51:15 PM »

S0n1c

  • Guest
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1912 on: October 01, 2015, 02:31:39 PM »
take further actions idc  8)

Offline Maddy`

  • VC-MP Donator
  • *
  • Posts: 466
  • ÃŒl Mìgìlòrè
  • Awards VC-MP Most Hated (2015)
    • Awards
  • SA-MP: Maddy
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1913 on: October 01, 2015, 02:35:57 PM »
I'll ban them  8) 8) 8) 8) 8) 8) 8)

I'm GTA V Admin

Offline BikeDriver

  • Fisher
  • ******
  • Posts: 1765
  • I can do anything
    • Awards
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1914 on: October 01, 2015, 02:41:57 PM »
I'll ban them  8) 8) 8) 8) 8) 8) 8)

I'm GTA V Admin

thx
BikeDriv:))))

Haha blwelrwelrt, I registered here earlier :P

OrlandoSK12

  • Guest
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1915 on: October 01, 2015, 03:03:21 PM »
Lolz bikedriver greate picks and vidjos but I don't understund that pause moment ???

Offline BikeDriver

  • Fisher
  • ******
  • Posts: 1765
  • I can do anything
    • Awards
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1916 on: October 01, 2015, 03:07:31 PM »
Lolz bikedriver greate picks and vidjos but I don't understund that pause moment ???

They paused their game to access a menu where they can vote to kick a player out...
BikeDriv:))))

Haha blwelrwelrt, I registered here earlier :P

Offline EnzoMortelli

Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1917 on: October 01, 2015, 11:24:43 PM »
Not going to shred your entire post apart, overall it makes sense, I admit.
overall it makes sense, I admit.
makes sense, I admit.
...



All these years i have waited...










...for this one astonishing moment.












   


Now i can finally retire. #2ndOctober2015neverforget.


edit in german: Das ich das nochmal erleben darf :')
« Last Edit: October 02, 2015, 11:34:35 AM by EnzoMortelli »

Offline Maddy`

  • VC-MP Donator
  • *
  • Posts: 466
  • ÃŒl Mìgìlòrè
  • Awards VC-MP Most Hated (2015)
    • Awards
  • SA-MP: Maddy
Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1918 on: October 02, 2015, 05:49:01 AM »
I'd like to see EnzoMortelli resign.

Offline Freak

Re: Post random stuff here
« Reply #1919 on: October 02, 2015, 07:03:43 AM »
so I have been surprised :( i slap my brother and i make the ban appeal :(