A separate server would divide the player base. I'd select the server with the better race script and never visit the other server. Each of us would select the element that they enjoy the most and never join the other server. Why would they?
Has anyone here ever registered an account on a roleplaying server and spent serious time playing? I'd imagine most of us haven't. The truth is, anybody who has already invested hundreds of hours into a roleplaying server isn't going to leave anytime soon. Why would they? And the handful of players that "server-hop" (the noobs we often see roaming our streets) are hackers looking for a playground. So, with those two facts considered, the number of new players that could potentially enter our server looking for a permanent home is extremely small when compared with the total number of active SA-MP players. There isn't much we can do about that.
In other words, most players are either already married, or just looking for a fuck.
How do we resolve this problem? Build a server that caters to a large palette of player desires with several unique "only-at-littlewhiteys" features integrated. Build an environment that feels like a home. Yes, this means we will need to cut ties with our "pure death-match" mentality, which I believe most of us have already done. We're actually well on our way to success. Disregarding the radical one-off player spikes, has our average player count increased since let's say this time last year? I don't have the data to support my answer, but I would assume it has.
I understand Fusez is permanently banned, but he has made some phenomenal game modes. Nitrous that can be injected manually with an actual meter - like a real car? He's done it. I can't even remember all of the fantastic ideas he's implemented in a test environment because the next idea immediately surpasses the last. His departure isn't insurmountable, but I'm going to tell you right now he holds the key to a quick turnaround. Just look at the Christmas snowfall in the server right now. Has anyone else seen that on other servers? I'm not saying his scripting ability exceeds that of RDL, but damn - that kid is creative as hell. He thinks of the coolest shit. The shit we need.